Dozens of Auckland homes compulsorily bought by council for flood relief plan

Source: Radio New Zealand

Close to 50 homes in an Auckland suburb are being compulsorily bought to make way for new flood plains and uncover a buried stream.

This is in Rānui, where some homeowners are relieved to get out, while others wish they could stay.

It’s just the start of Auckland Council’s plan to reduce the risk in flood-prone areas of the region and it says there are more property acquisitions ahead.

Emily Stewart is one of those affected. RNZ / Marika Khabazi

Emily Stewart, her husband and two children moved out of their house in Rānui’s Clover Drive a few weeks ago.

It’s been bought under the Public Works Act because a piped stream is being uncovered.

“The stream is going to come through approximately through here…right through our house.”

On Sunday, the home was relocated to Waikato.

default RNZ / Marika Khabazi

Stewart said they planned to sell the house three years ago before the storms hit – some of her neighbours had to kayak from their houses.

The Stewarts weren’t eligible for a risky-home buyout, so had repairs done, then learned their house would be acquired to daylight a stream and create a flood plain.

The family has bought and moved to another part of the city.

“It’s bittersweet because for three years we were just stuck in this limbo. Back in October all of the houses in this cresent were still standing in various states of decay,” Stewart said.

Close to 50 homes in an Auckland suburb are being compulsorily bought to make way for new flood plains and uncover a buried stream. RNZ / Marika Khabazi

‘We need this land’ – council

Auckland Council’s head of sustainable partnerships Tom Mansell said of the almost 50 homes required for flood plains in Rānui, half were state owned.

“Some of these properties, most of them have been flooded, some of them have been partially flooded, some of them haven’t been flooded but we need this land to save other surrounding properties from flooding.”

He said it would save 100 properties and also enable future development.

The Rānui Making Space for Water project is costing $85 million, of which most – close to $50m – is for buying properties.

“It’s digging up the pipe, creating the flood plain, creating the stream, upgrading Don Buck Road bridge,” Mansell said.

“It’s transforming communities, it is disruptive, it is costly but moving forward with climate change and increased rainfall it is a new era in managing stormwater.”

RNZ / Marika Khabazi

Mansell said negotiating with homeowners was a sensitive process.

“Some homeowners are relieved it is a way out, a fresh start for them and some not so much, it’s really quite hard hitting. Some of them have been there 30 to 40 years and it’s their home, there’s a reluctance to leave.”

He said there will be more homes acquired to make way for flood plains in coming years as the council confirms other projects.

“Overall, it creates more greenspace, creates resilient communities and it’s the way of the future for managing stormwater.”

Clover Drive in Henderson in Auckland. RNZ / Marika Khabazi

Reluctant to leave

Another Clover Drive homeowner, Wayne Macdonald, didn’t want to leave but accepted a Public Works Act buyout.

“I was hoping to stay,” he said.

“I was disappointed, I like my house. I like its location, I like how it’s close to everything and I didn’t really look forward to looking for a new house and I’m struggling to find something.”

He was aware the acquisition was compulsory and said the financial incentives for accepting a buyout within certain timeframes made it more attractive.

The Momutu Stream. RNZ / Marika Khabazi

Macdonald said the plans to create a bigger stream and flood plain included walking paths and reserve areas.

“What they’re doing is actually really nice and for a lot of neighbourhoods around, it’s going to give them options. They’re going to be able to walk away from the streets and pollution of the cars, kids are going to have areas to go play.”

Further along the road, Donna Mather’s home is not in a flood zone.

There are already many vacant plots from houses that were too risky to live in and she said having more homes go with compulsory acquisitions will change the neighbourhood.

“A lady friend up on Universal Drive, she will be moving because she was bought out. Apparently her place is going to be a pond.”

Donna Mather RNZ / Marika Khabazi

Under the Public Works Act, councils or agencies buying properties can only inform property owners – not tenants.

Stewart said this created problems on her street, because some neighbours were only recently informed by their landlords who have to give 90 days notice to end a tenancy.

“They were completely rug-pulled, like what’s going on, what’s happening I’m getting conflicting information.”

She said that needed to change.

“What I’m seeing is that we are prioritising homeowners over people who are renting and that’s not how this society should be supporting each other,” Stewart said.

“The fact that I’ve been told that they are having to look at work-arounds means there’s something wrong with the law. There is an oversight with the laws that they are bound by,” she said.

“The way we can make change for the better for people is to say ‘this isn’t working’.”

RNZ / Marika Khabazi

Mansell said the council strongly encouraged landlords to inform tenants if their house was being bought out – and tenants have access to financial support during the process.

“We encourage them strongly to talk to their tenants and we have a community advisory group which meets every two weeks…so we try and keep as much information about what we’re doing, the overall layout of the project is out in the community,” Mansell said.

“That’s one way the information gets out but unfortunately we cannot contact the tenants directly, we have to go through the landlord.”

The compulsory buyouts come as the region is under pressure to intensify housing and build more homes and the council was preparing plans to accommodate up to 2 million homes in coming decades.

However last month, Cabinet agreed to lower the maximum number of houses in Auckland from 2 million to at least 1.6 million.

Mansell said houses needed to be built in safe areas.

“The last thing we want to do is more development with houses in the wrong place in a danger zone so we are watching and working with this plan change. We don’t want to create more issues moving forward.”

RNZ / Marika Khabazi

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

LiveNews: https://nz.mil-osi.com/2026/03/04/dozens-of-auckland-homes-compulsorily-bought-by-council-for-flood-relief-plan/

The 5am myth: Waking early won’t make you more successful

Source: Radio New Zealand

At 5am, social media fills with proof that the early risers have already won the day. Cold plunges. Journals. Sunrise runs. Productivity gurus insist this is the routine that separates high performers from everyone else, reinforced by high-profile early risers such as Apple CEO Tim Cook, entrepreneur Richard Branson and Hollywood actor Jennifer Aniston.

The message is simple: wake earlier, perform better. But the science tells a more complicated story. For many people, a 5am routine clashes with their biology and can undermine both health and productivity. Much depends on your individual biological rhythm, or “chronotype”.

Chronotypes reflect when people naturally feel alert or sleepy, and genetics play a major role in shaping them. Research shows that sleep timing is partly rooted in our genes, and chronotype is heritable. Chronotype also shifts across the lifespan, with adolescents tending toward later sleep pattern and older adults often shifting earlier. Most people are not extreme larks or owls, but fall somewhere in between.

Jennifer Aniston loves an early start to the day.

SHAUN CURRY/AFP

LiveNews: https://nz.mil-osi.com/2026/03/04/the-5am-myth-waking-early-wont-make-you-more-successful/

Green fuel needs a leg-up to be viable, modelling shows

Source: Radio New Zealand

Auckland University economic modelling has found green hydrogen could have some limited use in future. 123RF

There are calls for more support for green fuel alternatives as the Middle East conflict exposes New Zealand’s vulnerability to fuel supply chain shocks.

Auckland University economic modelling has found green hydrogen – hydrogen produced by renewables – could have some limited use in future for industries heavily reliant on gas and coal for production.

But cost and limited infrastucture remained major barriers, as did a lack of government policy.

“If we can use renewable electricity, wind, for example, or possibly geothermal as a source of electricity, then that is an attractive option,” Auckland University energy economist Professor Basil Sharp said.

“But until such time as the technology improves and we can get the costs down, it’s going to be somewhere out in the future.”

As the government pushes ahead with a liquified natural gas import facility and global LNG prices soared as a result of Qatar halting production, Sharp said more attention needed to be paid to New Zealand’s energy independence.

“There could be an unintended impact associated with promoting importation of LNG that could and I’m not saying it will, but it could have an impact on the rollout of our renewables.

“It could have an impact on the technology, such as the viability of green hydrogen going forward.”

Green hydrogen a bit player in road to net zero

The modelling found that at best, green hydrogen was capable of supplying about 12 percent of industrial process heat energy by 2050 .

Because it was so expensive to produce, green hydrogen needed the right conditions to be viable and was more attractive when carbon prices were higher, renewable electricity was cheaper, and hydrogen technology costs fell.

It was in those scenarios researchers said hydrogen could play a complementary role in helping New Zealand reach net zero emissions, but electrification was still the key.

“Even if they are making very small contributions to our energy independence when the technology and and the costs come down, we need to be in a position, to take advantage of that and actually promote the utilisation of hydrogen in the economy,” said Sharp.

A new export for NZ?

One of the model’s co-authors and senior economics lecturer Le Wen said New Zealand was already well-placed to produce green hydrogen because 80 percent of our electricity was renewable.

Wen said that if the country invested in and scaled up green hydrogen production, the country could become a leader in genuinely low-emissions hydrogen.

“It may not solve everything on its own, but it could give the country a strong new export opportunity,” he said.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

LiveNews: https://nz.mil-osi.com/2026/03/04/green-fuel-needs-a-leg-up-to-be-viable-modelling-shows/

Live: Israel launches fresh attacks on Iran and Beirut, Iran continues strikes across Gulf

Source: Radio New Zealand

Follow the latest with our live blog above

Fresh strikes have hit half a dozen countries across the Middle East in the widening conflict surrounding Iran.

The latest blasts were reported in Iran, Israel, Lebanon, Bahrain, Qatar and the United Arab Emirates, as Israel urged countries to cut ties with Iran.

Israel said its air force had launched a new “large scale” wave of strikes “targeting the Iranian terror regime’s infrastructure in Tehran”, following the latest salvo of missiles fired from Iran, including in Tel Aviv and in several sites in central Israel.

Iran, in turn, appealed to the UN Security Council to step in, while warning of more intense attacks on US forces and Israel as the war raged for the fourth day.

Iranian drones struck the US embassy in Saudi Arabia after previously hitting the mission in Kuwait.

In Lebanon, air strikes hit Beirut’s southern suburbs, an area where Hezbollah holds sway, while Hezbollah said it had targeted a military facility in Israel in response.

Israel ordered its forces to take control of more positions inside Lebanon to create a buffer zone, and the Lebanese army pulled back some of its forces.

Explosions were also heard in the Bahraini and Qatari capitals of Manama and Doha.

The International Atomic Energy Agency said a key Iranian nuclear site, Natanz, was damaged, but “no radiological consequence” was expected.

The UN refugee agency said the escalation of hostilities has displaced at least 30,000 people in Lebanon, and the Iranian Red Crescent said more than 780 people have been killed nationwide.

Follow the latest with our live blog at the top of this page.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

LiveNews: https://nz.mil-osi.com/2026/03/04/live-israel-launches-fresh-attacks-on-iran-and-beirut-iran-continues-strikes-across-gulf/

Rising Kiwi Ollie Dunbar pulls off major upset at NZ Squash Open

Source: Radio New Zealand

Ollie Dunbar in action against Velavan Senthilkumar at the New Zealand Squash Open. Professional Squash Association

New Zealand teenage wildcard Ollie Dunbar has caused a major boilover on the opening day of the New Zealand Squash Open in Christchurch, toppling a top-50 ranked opponent.

The 18-year-old stunned world No.49 Velavan Senthilkumar in five games at the Isaac Theatre Royal venue.

The world No.125 needed just over an hour to prevail 11-8, 11-6, 6-11, 2-11, 11-5, staving off a mid-game fightback from his Indian opponent.

It comes 12 months after recording his maiden World Events win – at the same tournament.

“It was nice to do it last year, there was a bit more pressure on me this time around. But I enjoy playing on this court, so I’m looking forward to another game on it tomorrow,” Dunbar said.

“Over the last year or so I’ve definitely got better at the mental side of my game. It was good to be able to come through after being 2-0 up and seeing him come back to force a fifth game.

“It’s an incredible court and stage here. I’m so happy to play on it whenever I can. It’s been great to have lots of my friends here and have some people from my club come down to watch me.”

Dunbar was to take on two-time world junior champion Mohamad Zakaria of Egypt in today’s second-round match.

Joelle King in action at the Nations Cup tournament in Tauranga. PHOTOSPORT

It was a tougher day for the New Zealand women, with Joelle King and Kaitlyn Watts both beaten in five games.

Former world No.3 and 11-time New Zealand champion King was making her return from injury, having last played on tour 10 months ago.

She went down 11-2, 7-11, 8-11, 11-7, 11-8 in 50 minutes to Canadian No.1 Hollie Naughton.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

LiveNews: https://nz.mil-osi.com/2026/03/04/rising-kiwi-ollie-dunbar-pulls-off-major-upset-at-nz-squash-open/

Ministry underestimated scale of secondary teacher shortage

Source: Radio New Zealand

Secondary schools need more teachers in the system than previously thought. File photo. Richard Tindiller

The Education Ministry has been underestimating the scale of the secondary teacher shortage, and says correcting its calculations caused this year’s jump in the forecast shortage.

The ministry last week forecast a likely shortfall of 1220 secondary teachers this year and next, up from last year’s projection of 880 for the same period.

The ministry’s education workforce head Anna Welanyk told RNZ the change was because the ministry previously assumed schools hired in outside teachers to cover about half of the time when their regular teachers were out of their classrooms due to factors such as non-contact time.

Welanyk said research last year showed that was true for primary schools, but not for secondary schools which used relief teachers for almost all of their teachers’ non-contact hours.

“We went out and talked to the sector to find out more information about exactly whether or not those assumptions were valid and determined that for primary, they were bang on and for secondary, they really weren’t,” she said.

She said that meant secondary schools needed more teachers in the system than previously thought.

“Because we changed the assumption to reflect what we understand to be something closer to the real life scenario, it’s meant that we’ve had to add on an additional 580-odd additional teachers into the secondary space.

“It’s not that the situation’s got dramatically worse or that our forecasting was not where it needed to be. It’s more that more detail in terms of the research that we’ve done has pointed us in a slightly different direction.”

She confirmed that it also meant the ministry had under-estimated demand for secondary teachers in previous forecasts.

Welanyk said without the change the ministry would have forecast a shortage of 140 rather than 710 secondary teachers this year.

“The situation, as described by the data in the report, is a more accurate reflection of the pressure on the system.”

In 2023, the ministry under-estimated demand for primary teachers after failing to account for changes to their collective agreement.

Meanwhile, Welanyk said there were early signs that enrolments in initial teacher education programmes had increased 30 percent his year.

“It’s very promising. It’s the highest increase that we’ve seen in quite a while, since before covid. So what that tells us is that people are interested in teaching as a profession. They do see it as a viable career path,” she said.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

LiveNews: https://nz.mil-osi.com/2026/03/04/ministry-underestimated-scale-of-secondary-teacher-shortage/

A gold mine, an Australia mining giant, and a community divided

Source: Radio New Zealand

A visual simulation released by Santana Minerals showing what the mine would look like from Māori Point Road, Tarras. Supplied

A proposed gold mine is on the fast-track list. Proponents says it will bring jobs and money to the region, but opponents say it will be an economic ‘short-term sugar hit … with long-term consequences’.

Plans for a large, open cast gold mine in Central Otago are pitting locals against each other, while a mining industry executive says New Zealanders are too negative and catastrophise projects they don’t understand.

Australian company Santana Minerals has applied for fast-track approval to build an open cast mine in the Dunstan mountain range, an hour’s drive east of Queenstown, after discovering what it calls the largest single gold deposit in New Zealand in more than four decades.

According to the documents submitted to the fast-track panel, Santana will build four open mine pits. The largest, Rise and Shine Open Pit will be one kilometre long, 800 metres wide and 200 metres deep. There will also be three shallower pits, a processing plant that is one kilometre long and 120 metres wide, and a tailing storage facility to store mineral waste dust.

It says the project will employ hundreds of people and be worth $6 billion in revenue and more than $1b in taxes and royalties for New Zealand.

The fast-track panel is set to decide by late October and, if approved, it will be the first new mine to get the go-ahead under the accelerated process.

Opponents fear it will destroy threatened plants, scar the unique landscape and pollute the land and water. They say New Zealand will not get all the economic benefits because Santana is an Australian company, and they warn it will open the door to more mining in the region.

Two main groups are campaigning against the mine with backing from famous residents including actor Sir Sam Neill and painter Sir Grahame Sydney, as well as the former prime minister Helen Clark.

One of the groups, Sustainable Tarras, has already been fighting plans to build an international airport near the town. It calls the Santana proposal ‘David versus Goliath’ and is asking for donations to fund experts to fully understand the economic, environmental and social impacts of the mine.

“We are fighting this hard,” it says on its website.

Artist Gregory O’Brien, who organised a fundraising exhibition for the group, says the “proposed desecration of a heritage area for purely monetary gain is an outrage to all of us, as it is to the citizens of Central Otago and to all New Zealanders”.

“Painters, photographers, writers, film-makers, choreographers and other arts practitioners from within Central Otago and further afield are incensed at the churlishness of both the mining consortium and the Government’s ruinous ‘fast-track’ (aka ‘Highway to Hell’) legislation.

“The environmental cost of such a cold-blooded, extractive exercise is simply too high, as is the social impact and down-stream legacy.”

On the other side, Santana Mine Supporters, a Facebook group with 6,800 members says Central Otago “deserves opportunity – higher-paid local jobs, stronger regional businesses, and meaningful investment back into our community. We also believe development must be done properly, with high standards, transparency, and long-term accountability.”

RNZ Central Otago reporter Katie Todd has spoken to many locals, including farmers who see it as a positive move for the region and a continuation of the area’s mining legacy.

She says the application has been drawn out.

“Santana Minerals were asking for it to be considered within 30 days or so and we’ve recently learnt it’s going to be more like 140 days.

“In part that’s because of iwi opposition. Kā Rūnaka, which is a collective of Otago hapū, has raised concerns about potential Treaty settlement breaches and their concerns were described by the panel convenor of the fast-track application as significant and immutable.

“So that’s going to be something to watch,” says Todd.

Matthew Sole of Central Otago Environmental Society says communities are divided over the mine.

“There’s a lot of tension in the community,” he says. “There are certainly a lot of people for it.

“It’s the comments you receive on social media when you try and put up a counter argument and the difficulty I find with it is it’s actually hard to have a conversation.”

Sole says many people are under financial pressure and are concerned about the country’s future.

“I take a wider, longer term view that we’ve got to move on from exploitation to economies that have a right relationship with our environment. I think we’ve got to change away from these extractive processes to more enduring relationships and regenerative relationships with the land.”

Sole has produced a YouTube video of the area that will be mined and points out unique, threatened plants and remnants of past mining endeavours that are part of its precious heritage that he says are at risk. He says the old mining era cannot be compared to today’s.

“We’re talking about two different things. The early mining was largely mining of individual endeavour and it was largely with human hands with the use of water,” he says.

The impact of modern mining is “devastating, it has lost its context and meaning because of the vast industrial scale by massive machinery. We’re not comparing like with like”.

In a story for Newsroom last week, Jill Herron wrote that nearly a million hectares across Otago, and another 100,000 in Southland, are now at various stages of being “pegged” by gold mining companies.

But chief executive of New Zealand Minerals Council, Josie Vidal, says people have no need to panic and “possibly none” of the areas that have been identified on a minerals map drawn up by Earth Sciences New Zealand will be mined.

Heightened interest in the area is driven by the record price of gold, she says. She believes many will be hobby gold miners and doubts there would be any other large mines like Santana that are at a serious stage.

“There’s a lot of interest in gold of the traditional gold mining areas of which Otago is one, and there’s quite a lot of interest from smaller prospectors who could do quite well out of getting a fairly small amount of gold because the price is so high.”

She calls the Santana proposal “a bog standard gold mine”.

“I’m mystified by the attention. It’s a gold mine like any other. There’s no reason for it not to proceed.”

When The Detail asked Santana for an interview, it replied in an email with a number of conditions.

On balance and representation it said, “Please confirm who else will be featured or interviewed, and whether local voices and businesses many of which support the project – not just high-profile critics – are being included to reflect the full spectrum of community sentiment”.

It later declined our interview request but referred us it its 9,400-page application.

In an email, it said it welcomes scrutiny.

“What we cannot support is the amplification of assertions that have already been addressed, in writing, in data, numerous interviews and expert reports – simply because they are emotive or convenient to repeat and you haven’t bothered to fact check their claims.

“If the program’s objective is balance and informed debate, then the technical evidence must sit alongside the sentiment.”

Check out how to listen to and follow The Detail here.

You can also stay up-to-date by liking us on Facebook or following us on Twitter.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

LiveNews: https://nz.mil-osi.com/2026/03/04/a-gold-mine-an-australia-mining-giant-and-a-community-divided/

MediMap failings likely to be canvassed as part of Manage My Health review

Source: Radio New Zealand

MediMap’s failings will likely be covered by the review into Manage My Health. RNZ/Calvin Samuel

MediMap’s failings will likely be covered by the review into Manage My Health, despite the recent data breach not being included by name.

The prescription portal was now being brought back online, having been down since 22 February, after it was discovered patient information had been changed.

MediMap said it had “rebuilt a secure production environment, completed a forensic review and validation of our data, identified the specific demographic records that were altered, and strengthened authentication controls, supported by independent cyber security specialists”.

All user passwords would be reset and any medication changes made manually during the outage would require clinical review, it said.

It acknowledged the “patience and professionalism” of healthcare staff dealing with manual processes, and apologised to residents, patients, families and healthcare providers for any disruption and distress.

A court injunction had been granted which prohibited anyone from accessing, using, copying, sharing or publishing any of the data.

The MediMap breach followed a hack of the patient portal ManageMyHealth (MMH) in late December, which sparked a review, commissioned by Health Minister Simeon Brown, to be carried out by the Ministry of Health.

The minister’s office said while MediMap would not be explicitly included by name in the review currently underway, the systemic issues which led to it would likely apply to both.

“The Ministry of Health’s review into the Manage My Health (MMH) cyber security incident is considering the broader issue of how private companies secure health data,” a spokesperson said.

A Ministry of Health spokesperson said the aim of the review was to understand the causes of the MMH breach, and the response, and to recommend improvements to ensure data breaches were better prevented in the future.

“While our focus remains on Manage My Health, the learnings will apply more broadly to other digital platforms which manage heath data.”

MediMap has been approached for comment.

On Thursday last week, Prime Minister Christopher Luxon said Cabinet had just signed off on a new cyber security policy and strategy.

“It’s entirely appropriate that we look at our whole settings, because we need to make sure we’ve got tougher cyber securities around our critical infrastructure.”

He also sent a strong message to businesses.

“The Kiwi laid-backness in a cyber security world where there are real risks and challenges is not good enough. You need to be investing, and making sure that your systems and your protocols are up to speed, and are actually on-point, and that they continually evolve.”

He said the government would be consulting on the problem over the next few months, and considering incentives and punishments.

Last week, Manage My Health began notifying a further group of patients affected by the December attack.

It did not respond to questions about why these people had not been notified earlier.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

LiveNews: https://nz.mil-osi.com/2026/03/04/medimap-failings-likely-to-be-canvassed-as-part-of-manage-my-health-review/

Is a mark on the wall ‘damage’? Landlords, tenants puzzle over wear and tear

Source: Radio New Zealand

RNZ

A “very small dent” or black mark on a wall. A Raro spill on the carpet. A broken mop and bucket.

These are some of the issues that have divided landlords and tenants who have appeared before the Tenancy Tribunal in the past month, working out what is “wear and tear” and what counts as “damage” to a rental property.

Tenancy Services says fair wear and tear refers to the gradual deterioration of things that are used regularly by people living in a property. Tenants are not responsible for this provided they are using the property, or the chattels provided, normally.

But tenants are responsible for intentional or careless damage.

“An example of this would be where a stove element wears out from normal cooking. This is fair wear and tear. However, if the stove was being used to heat the kitchen and stopped working properly, this would not be considered normal use.”

It’s an issue that can cause a lot of consternation.

In one case heard last month, a landlord sought compensation for the $28.82 cost of replacing a mop and bucket, among more expensive items.

The adjudicator said the evidence did not prove the damage to the mop and bucket was more than normal wear and tear.

But in another, a tenant’s former partner spilled Raro on the carpet and the adjudicator was “satisfied that the damage was caused carelessly”.

Last month, a landlord who argued the walls had been damaged was told one area of damage looked to be a “very small dent or black mark” and fair wear and tear.

Another landlord was told that there was not enough evidence that the tenant caused damage by causing chips on a granite bench top or pin holes to her walls.

Cassie Metcalfe, of iRentProperty, said there was confusion among landlords and tenants about how the rules might apply.

“When we think of what’s reasonable, different people will have different interpretations of that.

“There’s a lot of things to consider. One is the number of occupants in the house, the length of the tenancy, the condition of things when the tenants first moved in. I think it takes all parties to apply a level of fairness and reasonableness to come to an agreement. There’s no clear cut line unfortunately.”

She said landlords should make sure their inspections were done to a good standard and records kept. Tenants should report issues.

“You want to make sure these are documented, photographed wherever possible. If there is wear and tear at the end of the tenancy this could end up going to the tribunal where the mediator or adjudicator is making a decision and they can rely on the evidence you have.”

Sarina Gibbon, director of Tenancy Advisory, agreed people entered tenancies with different expectations.

She said wear and tear could be thought of as “time doing its thing” while damage was “someone not doing their job”.

“When I reflect on talking to landlords and tenants it’s always that expectation if you’re on the landlord side of the equation that you expect the property to be left in a pristine condition – that the tenant should take extra care as if they own the property. Let’s be honest, we’ve all hired a car before, we know how we treat a hire car … it’s really about the relationship rather than nitpicking the little things.”

She said having a bit of room to move meant tenants and landlords had to engage with common sense and be pragmatic.

“In a way it is good that wear and tear is not strictly defined – I’m not convinced that it would serve the benefit of the sector to have it strictly defined but I understand that from a day to day it does create some frustration.

“When people are trying to nitpick a tenant for $30 damage I would say the problem isn’t the $30 problem, your biggest problem is that it is not a productive relationship.”

She said landlords were often caught out by betterment. They cannot expect to be put back into a position that is better than they were in before the damage occurred.

“The tribunal is consistently good at accounting for betterment when it is ordering compensation. If the tenant had damaged something the tribunal would say – let’s say we’re talking about carpet … the tribunal will account for the fact that it is 10-year-old carpet, you’re not going to get replacement value.

“This isn’t an insurance policy, this is about restoring the landlord back to the position the landlord would have been in if the damage had never occurred. I don’t think people go into the process expecting that they get betterment, they don’t consciously think about it because think they ‘I have to put in a new carpet so the tenant should pay for the carpet – what they don’t account for is the carpet had deteriorated for 10 years.”

NZ Property Investors Federation spokesman Matt Ball said that was a bigger problem.

“On the face of it, this seems like fair principle, however the practical application of it sometimes results in significant financial harm to the landlord. For example, you may have a perfectly good five-year-old dishwasher that has been fully depreciated, with a book value of zero. The tenant can literally destroy this appliance and the landlord cannot claim any compensation, even though the appliance may have had many years of useful service left.

“The reason for this unfairness is that depreciation isn’t a measure of the item’s actual value. Depreciation is an agreed way a business owner can offset the cost of assets against income over time. It is never a full recovery of the cost of the asset, so if the asset is damaged or destroyed, the landlord is left out of pocket. In the same way that insurance policies often have an agreed value for items covered, it would be good if the law was changed to allow the Tenancy Tribunal to set an agreed value for destroyed or damaged assets so that landlords aren’t financially disadvantaged when a tenant causes actual damage.”

He pointed to a case last year in which a landlord said insurance had covered a claim up to $15,000 for meth contamination but the cost had been $18,000 more.

The adjudicator said that after three years, things like linen, bedding, crockery and cutlery were deemed to have no value for tax purposes. The adjudicator said when things were taken out of the claim that had no residual value, there was $10,836 in damaged goods – below the insurer’s payout.

“What strikes me in this case is that the landlord is left worse off, even though, as the adjudicator states in their ruling, ‘the landlord should be returned to the position they would have been in had the tenant not breached their obligations, and should not be better or worse off’,” Ball said.

Sign up for Money with Susan Edmunds , a weekly newsletter covering all the things that affect how we make, spend and invest money.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

LiveNews: https://nz.mil-osi.com/2026/03/04/is-a-mark-on-the-wall-damage-landlords-tenants-puzzle-over-wear-and-tear/

Generational shift sees younger investors choosing managed funds over property

Source: Radio New Zealand

Younger investors are choosing KiwiSaver over property. RNZ

Traditional property investment is losing ground to KiwiSaver and other managed funds as a preferred way to make money.

ASB’s latest Investor Confidence Survey for the fourth quarter ended in December (Q4) indicated owning your own home or having a property investment was no longer seen as providing the best returns among those surveyed.

Instead, KiwiSaver and managed funds emerged as the top two performers in the eyes of investors.

ASB senior economist Chris Tennent-Brown said the survey identified a shift in perceptions on what could deliver the strongest investment returns.

“Pretty amazing to see housing knocked off the perch,” he said.

“Despite all the global uncertainty, strong KiwiSaver and managed investment funds, those returns are flowing through to confidence in those products and outshining housing.”

The December (Q4) survey also indicated investor confidence rose 11 percent over the third quarter (Q3), with the lower North Island reporting the most significant rise with confidence rising to 10 percent in Q4, compared with 3 percent in Q3.

He said there had been a generational shift since the 1987 stock market crash saw large numbers of New Zealanders’ investments in shares.

“The generational divide is apparent with the over 60s holding steady in their belief that your own home is still the best investment, which is unsurprising.

“Gen Z on the other hand believe the best returns currently lie in investing in shares of publicly listed companies, signalling the rise of the DIY investor as an accessible path to growing your portfolio.”

Tennent-Brown said the survey underscored the importance of financial education and the evolving needs of investors.

“The under 30s have been leading the way in this shift in sentiment for some time, however this quarter’s findings show a change in sentiment among most other age groups.”

However, he said New Zealanders continued to be interested in buying homes to live in, as indicated in the increase in confidence in our Housing Confidence survey.

“I think it’s really interesting to see people hopefully separating housing as a way of putting a roof over your head, which of course is a big part of our security and aspiration in New Zealand, versus investment returns,” Tennent-Brown said.

“It just means perception of property as an investment is evolving.”

The ASB investor confidence survey had been tracking NZ market sentiment since 1997.

The latest survey was based on 672 online interviews in Q4 2025 with adults aged 18 years and older throughout New Zealand. A sample of this size had a maximum margin of error of 3.8 percent at the 95 percent confidence level. Fieldwork occurred between 1October – 16 December 2025.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

LiveNews: https://nz.mil-osi.com/2026/03/04/generational-shift-sees-younger-investors-choosing-managed-funds-over-property/

Survivor ‘angry and saddened’ as number of young people abused in care increases

Source: Radio New Zealand

State abuse survivor Keith Wiffin. Reece Baker/RNZ

A man who was abused in state care is “angry and saddened” that the number of children and young people being abused in care has continued to increase.

The Independent Children’s Monitor’s latest report said 530 tamaraki and rangatahi were abused in state care during the 2024/25 year, up from 507 during the 2023/24 year.

State abuse survivor Keith Wiffin said that was difficult for him and many other survivors to hear.

“In particular the 3000 courageous survivors who gave testimony to the royal comission on the basis that the appalling rates of abuse that continue would cease and we would see change and improvement.”

But he said the government and faith based institutions had not made enough changes after the Royal Comission on Abuse in Care.

“They have generally ignored the findings and recommendations of the royal comission, and therefore been contemptous of it, and that’s played a role in these continuing appalling rates of abuse.”

Keith Wiffin was abused in state care in the 1970s at Epuni boys home in the Hutt Valley and testified to the Royal Comission.

He said tinkering with the care system would not work, and fundamental change was needed for things to improve.

“That approach is: families, communties, iwi, hapu need to be resourced to look after their own. The best way to stop abuse in care is to see our young don’t go into care in the first place.”

Keith Wiffin said during his time in state care, he had a good social worker but he was completely overworked with a caseload of 80 boys.

Independent Children’s Monitor chief executive, Arran Jones, said social workers being overworked was still a problem today.

“Social workers spend a lot of time trying to find homes for young people that have to be removed from mum and dad … so that places pressure on the social work day job.

“The second thing is trying to access the help these kids need – so time taken negotiating with health and education over who will pay for supports.”

The report found a third of tamariki and rangatahi were not being visited by their social worker as often as they should be.

It also highlighted problems acessing health and education services, and Jones suggested prioritising tamaraki and rangatahi in care for these services over the general population.

“Because what the evidence tells us is tamariki in care have far worse outcomes into their adult lives than other children.”

Oranga Tamariki has been working on a National Care Standards Action Plan since early last year which Jones hoped would make a difference.

“This is the first time in the six years I’ve seen Oranga Tamariki commit to a very clear actionable plan. So this is a positive sign.”

Minister responds

Minister for Children Karen Chhour. RNZ / Samuel Rillstone

Minister for Children Karen Chhour said turning around generations of failures would not happen overnight, but she believed the most recent data from Oranga Tamariki showed progress was being made towards a stronger safety net for young people in care.

Chhour acknowledged the report identified silos and gaps between government agencies and said she had spoken to ministerial colleagues about working more closely together.

She said she was particularly proud of the progress towards working more closely with communities, strategic partners, and iwi and hapu

Oranga Tamariki responds

Oranga Tamariki chief social worker Nicolette Dickson. RNZ / Samuel Rillstone

Oranga Tamariki chief social worker, Nicolette Dickson, said it had seen performance improvements in eight out of the 10 focus areas in the National Care Standards Action Plan, and was confident about seeing sustained improvements through a focus on that work.

Dickson said more tamariki were being supported to remain safely with their whānau, and of those surveyed, 96 percent of children in care said they felt safe, 90 percent felt supported to achieve their goals and 89 percent felt they had somewhere to belong.

She agreed there were a number of areas to improve on, but said the organisation was on the right track to address them.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

LiveNews: https://livenews.co.nz/2026/03/04/survivor-angry-and-saddened-as-number-of-young-people-abused-in-care-increases/

Live: Israel launches fresh strikes on Iran and Beirut

Source: Radio New Zealand

Follow the latest with our live blog above

Fresh strikes have hit half a dozen countries across the Middle East in the widening conflict surrounding Iran.

The latest blasts were reported in Iran, Israel, Lebanon, Bahrain, Qatar and the United Arab Emirates, as Israel urged countries to cut ties with Iran.

Israel said its air force had launched a new “large scale” wave of strikes “targeting the Iranian terror regime’s infrastructure in Tehran”, following the latest salvo of missiles fired from Iran, including in Tel Aviv and in several sites in central Israel.

Iran, in turn, appealed to the UN Security Council to step in, while warning of more intense attacks on US forces and Israel as the war raged for the fourth day.

In Lebanon, air strikes hit Beirut’s southern suburbs, an area where Hezbollah holds sway, while Hezbollah said it had targeted a military facility in Israel in response.

Israel ordered its forces to take control of more positions inside Lebanon to create a buffer zone, and the Lebanese army pulled back some of its forces.

Explosions were also heard in the Bahraini and Qatari capitals of Manama and Doha.

The International Atomic Energy Agency said a key Iranian nuclear site, Natanz, was damaged, but “no radiological consequence” was expected.

The UN refugee agency said the escalation of hostilities has displaced at least 30,000 people in Lebanon, and the Iranian Red Crescent said more than 780 people have been killed nationwide.

Follow the latest with our live blog at the top of this page.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

LiveNews: https://livenews.co.nz/2026/03/04/live-israel-launches-fresh-strikes-on-iran-and-beirut/

In pictures: Only lunar eclipse of 2026 graces NZ skies

Source: Radio New Zealand

The elipse at its max, taken from Wai-iti Dark Sky Park in Tasman. Supplied / Brent

Budding astronomers and photographers have ditched sleep overnight to lay eyes on a total lunar eclipse over New Zealand – from what one expert says is the “best seat in the world”.

The only lunar eclipse of 2026, also known as a blood moon, began just before 10pm on Tuesday.

Stardome astronomer Josh Aoraki earlier told RNZ lunar eclipses were not rare per se – the rarity was whether or not it was visible from your location.

“For this one in particular, we really have the best seat in the world, really. It’s really only visible for its entirety over the Pacific. And it’s the only one that we’re going to see this year. I don’t think we have another until 2028, about two years.”

Missed out? Never fear, there are other astronomical phenomenon to look forward to throughout the year.

Here’s what the view looked like from across New Zealand:

3 March – 11:32pm: The start of the eclipse is visible to Aucklanders as one side of the moon begins to darken. RNZ/Calvin Samuel

A photo taken at 9.37pm in Omarama over the Benmore Ranges in the South Island. Supplied / Fiona Chamberlain

4 March – 12:04am: red is visible to the naked eye as the moon is engulfed. RNZ/Calvin Samuel

4 March – 12:30am: The eclipse in near totality as the moon becomes a deep copper red. RNZ/Calvin Samuel

The moon at different stages of eclipse. Supplied / Nick McLean

As seen from Nelson. Supplied / Sonja Walker

On the way to the total eclipse, as seen from Karaka in South Auckland. Supplied / Scott Baird

Supplied / Brent

The moon above a building in Auckland. Supplied

The elipse at its max, taken from Wai-iti Dark Sky Park in Tasman. Supplied / Brent

Supplied / Alex P

Supplied / Alex P

A shot taken at the University of Canterbury Students’ Space Association telescope night. Supplied / Victoria Ding

Supplied / Alex P

Supplied / Alex P

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

LiveNews: https://livenews.co.nz/2026/03/04/in-pictures-only-lunar-eclipse-of-2026-graces-nz-skies/

ASB Investor confidence survey: Shift in investment sentiment as traditional property investments lose ground to KiwiSaver and managed funds

Source: ASB

Investor confidence has lifted to 11% according to ASB’s latest Investor Confidence Survey for the fourth quarter to December 31 2025, a slight increase from 10% in Q3. The lower North Island reported the most significant rise, jumping from 3% in Q3 to 10% in Q4, up 7%.

The survey reveals a shift in New Zealanders’ perceptions of where the strongest investment returns lie. For the first time in years, owning your own home or having a property investment are no longer seen as providing the best returns on balance among those surveyed.

Instead, KiwiSaver and managed funds have emerged as the top two performers in the eyes of investors, reflecting growing confidence in diversified and professionally managed investment options.

ASB senior economist Chris Tennent-Brown explains, “While property has long been considered the gold standard for investment, Kiwi are increasingly recognising the value and convenience of managed funds and the long-term benefits of KiwiSaver, favouring the flexibility and potential for growth.

The under 30s have been leading the way in this shift in sentiment for some time, however this quarter’s findings show a change in sentiment among most other age groups.

“The generational divide is apparent with the over 60s holding steady in their belief that your own home is still the best investment, which is unsurprising. Gen Z on the other hand believe the best returns currently lie in investing in shares of publicly listed companies, signalling the rise of the DIY investor as an accessible path to growing your portfolio,” says Chris.

“Despite this shift, New Zealanders continue to be interested in buying homes to live in, as indicated in the increase in confidence in our Housing Confidence survey. It just means perception of property as an investment is evolving.”

The survey underscores the importance of financial education and the evolving needs of investors as they seek robust and reliable options in a dynamic economic environment.

Notes:

ASB has tracked investor confidence in the NZ market since 1997. This analysis is based on 672 online interviews in Q4 2025 with adults aged 18 years and older throughout New Zealand. A sample of this size has a maximum margin of error of 3.8% at the 95% confidence level. Fieldwork occurred between 1st October – 16th December 2025.

MIL OSI

LiveNews: https://livenews.co.nz/2026/03/04/asb-investor-confidence-survey-shift-in-investment-sentiment-as-traditional-property-investments-lose-ground-to-kiwisaver-and-managed-funds/

DFI Retail Group Holdings Limited 2025 Preliminary Announcement Of Results

Source: Media Outreach

DFI Retail Group (the Group) is a leading Asian retailer, driven by its purpose to ‘Sustainably Serve Asia for Generations with Everyday Moments’.
At 31 December 2025, the Group and its associates operated 7,580 outlets across 12 markets, of which 5,529 stores were operated by subsidiaries. The Group, together with associates, employed over 79,000 people, with some 42,000 people employed by subsidiaries. The Group had reported revenue of US$8.9 billion in 2025.
The Group is dedicated to delivering quality, value and service to Asian consumers through a compelling retail experience, supported by an extensive store network and highly efficient supply chains.
The Group and its associates, operates a portfolio of well-known brands across five key divisions. The principal brands are:

Health and Beauty

• Mannings on the Chinese mainland, Hong Kong and Macau S.A.R.; Guardian in Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore and Vietnam.

Convenience

• 7-Eleven in Hong Kong and Macau S.A.R., Singapore and Southern China.

Food

• Wellcome and Market Place in Hong Kong S.A.R.; San Miu in Macau S.A.R.; Lucky in Cambodia.

Home Furnishings

• IKEA in Hong Kong and Macau S.A.R., Indonesia and Taiwan.

Restaurants

• Hong Kong Maxim’s group on the Chinese mainland, Hong Kong and Macau S.A.R., Cambodia, Laos, Malaysia, Singapore, Thailand and Vietnam.

The Group’s parent company, DFI Retail Group Holdings Limited, is incorporated in Bermuda and has a primary listing in the equity shares (transition) category of the London Stock Exchange, with secondary listings in Bermuda and Singapore. The Group’s businesses are managed from Hong Kong. DFI Retail Group is a member of the Jardine Matheson group.

– Published and distributed with permission of Media-Outreach.com.

LiveNews: https://livenews.co.nz/2026/03/04/dfi-retail-group-holdings-limited-2025-preliminary-announcement-of-results/

Tourism satellite account: Year ended March 2025 – Stats NZ information release

MIL OSI

LiveNews: https://livenews.co.nz/2026/03/04/tourism-satellite-account-year-ended-march-2025-stats-nz-information-release/

New home consents rise in January – Building consents issued: January 2026 – Stats NZ news story and information release

MIL OSI

LiveNews: https://livenews.co.nz/2026/03/04/new-home-consents-rise-in-january-building-consents-issued-january-2026-stats-nz-news-story-and-information-release/

Vinhomes Green Paradise Launches Global Smart City Certification Project

Source: Media Outreach

HANOI, VIETNAM – Media OutReach Newswire – 3 March 2026 – Vinhomes Green Paradise – Can Gio has officially launched its Smart City Certification Project in collaboration with Korea Management Association Consulting (KMAC), the World Council on City Data (WCCD), and the Standardized Urban Metrics (SUM) initiative. Through this initiative, Vinhomes Green Paradise aims to become the first internationally certified smart city in Vietnam, thereby establishing new global standards for sustainable and intelligent urban development.

Vinhomes Green Paradise features an exceptional collection of world-class amenities, setting a new standard of living for a future-ready urban development.

The partnership is designed to support the mega development in achieving the WCCD/SUM Custom ISO 37122 Smart City Certification. This certification is based on a customized indicators framework derived from the internationally recognized ISO 37122 indicators, tailored specifically for greenfield development projects and urban areas.

Under the partnership, KMAC will provide strategic consulting and technical advisory services to align the city’s development with the ISO 37122 indicators across key domains such as mobility, energy, environment, safety, and digital infrastructure.

The WCCD and SUM, headquartered in Toronto, Canada, is preparing a new customized indicators framework for greenfield development, based on the strategic smart city goals in the Vinhomes Green Paradise development. The WCCD/SUM teams, will oversee the assessment and smart city certification process, ensuring compliance with the ISO international standards and best practices.

The consortium agreed on a roadmap to deliver an Interim Certification within 2026, paving the way for full certification in subsequent phases.

“This project symbolizes a landmark collaboration between Vietnam and Korea in advancing global smart city standards,” said Mr. Chulse Oh, Head of AX Group at KMAC. “By combining Vinhomes’ visionary urban development with KMAC’s consulting expertise and WCCD/SUM’s global certification framework, VinhomesGreen Paradise will become a model for data-driven governance, sustainability, and smart innovation.”

“Vietnam is emerging as one of the most promising leaders in smart and sustainable city development. The Vinhomes Green Paradise is a remarkable new development in Vietnam that deserves global recognition,” said Dr. Patricia McCarney, President & CEO of the World Council on City Data (WCCD) and Director of SUM. “We are honored to partner with Vinhomes and KMAC to ensure that Vinhomes Green Paradise achieves global recognition through our WCCD/SUM ISO 37122 Custom Certification.”

Vinhomes Green Paradise benefits from a rare geographical setting, surrounded by the Can Gio Sea and the UNESCO-recognized Can Gio Mangrove Biosphere Reserve spanning over 75,000 hectares. The project features a 121-kilometer coastline, a total scale of 2,870 hectares, and a construction density of only 16%. It pioneers an upgraded ESG++ model, structured around five pillars: Environment, Social, Governance, Regeneration, and Climate Adaptation.

Upon full operation, the entire urban management system will be comprehensively greened with the following objectives: 100% clean electricity sourced from offshore wind farms, solar energy systems, and battery storage; 100% net-zero emission transportation, including electric cars, electric scooters, electric buses, electric bicycles, electric boats, and a high-speed railway system directly connecting to central Ho Chi Minh City.

In addition to strict compliance with environmental protection standards, Vinhomes Green Paradise places strong emphasis on biodiversity conservation and ecosystem regeneration throughout the development process, aligned with Ho Chi Minh City’s long-term climate adaptation strategy. A Forest Regeneration and Climate Adaptation Fund has been established to support research, restoration, and long-term resilience initiatives, with a core focus on mangrove restoration in Can Gio to establish a protective green belt for the entire development.

With its pioneering ESG vision, Vinhomes Green Paradise has become the first official participant in the “7 Wonders of the Future Cities” campaign initiated by New7Wonders, reinforcing its global recognition as a benchmark model for sustainable, AI-ready, and data-driven urban innovation.

Hashtag: #Vinhomes

The issuer is solely responsible for the content of this announcement.

– Published and distributed with permission of Media-Outreach.com.

LiveNews: https://livenews.co.nz/2026/03/04/vinhomes-green-paradise-launches-global-smart-city-certification-project/

Australia’s Middle East military HQ hit in Iranian drone attack, Qatar halts LNG production

Source: Radio New Zealand

Follow the latest with our live blog above

US President Donald Trump is warning ‘a big wave’ of strikes against Iran is yet to come.

Speaking to CNN, Trump said the US hasn’t even begun to hit the Iranian regime hard.

Missile strikes continued to fly over the Middle East overnight, with multiple countries threatening escalation of the ongoing conflict.

Top members of the Trump administration have spoken publicly about ‘Operation Epic Fury’ for the first time at a Pentagon press conference. The US said the goal of the war was not regime change, despite the deaths of top Iranian leaders, including Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei.

US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth said the United States was not ruling out any options in the war, but promised, “This is not Iraq … This is not endless”.

Meanwhile, Iran said it was ready for a “long war” and has targeted US military bases in other Gulf states.

Kuwait said it accidentally shot down “several” US military aircraft in friendly fire.

Iran-backed Hezbollah and Israel continue to trade blows, prompting the Lebanese government to ban Hezbollah’s military and security activities and call on the group to hand over its weapons to the state.

Trump has said he envisages the conflict could last four weeks.

Follow the latest with our live log at the top of this page.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

LiveNews: https://nz.mil-osi.com/2026/03/04/australias-middle-east-military-hq-hit-in-iranian-drone-attack-qatar-halts-lng-production/

Labour changes tune on welfare claw backs

Source: Radio New Zealand

If the law was retrospectively passed it would effectively criminalise people who need help, not debt, Willie Jackson says. RNZ / Samuel Rillstone

The Labour Party has changed its tune on legislation that would allow MSD to legally claw back welfare payments once someone has been backpaid for an ACC claim.

Though it still looks set to pass with all three coalition partners on board.

The Ministry of Social Development (MSD) has been billing people for supplementary support, like the winter energy payment, once they have received a lump sum from the Accident Compensation Corporation.

The High Court ruled this long-standing policy illegal in late 2025.

One week ago, the Minister for Social Development Louise Upston moved a motion of urgency in the House to align the law to stop what the government described as ‘double dipping’ – legislation that would apply retrospectively.

Lawyers and health professionals urged the government to slow down on the change in a shortened Select Committee stage last week, arguing vulnerable people – including state abuse survivors and mothers with birth injuries – would be among those caught up in the change.

Ten experts also went as far as writing to Upston last Friday to warn her “the bill goes significantly further” than the government stated objective required and “risks producing serious inequity and unintended harm”.

The group suggested seven targeted amendments to the bill, including a provision where MSD could not claw back payments that were received in good faith, and where they would be inequitable.

Labour ‘cannot ignore’ concerns raised, suggests changes

At first reading, Labour’s Willie Jackson said if his party was in government it would “also be seriously looking” at the law change as “double-dipping” should always be avoided.

On Tuesday, he told the House the feedback he’d heard last week “raised serious concerns we simply cannot ignore”.

Jackson said the reality was many MSD clients waiting for an ACC payment were worse off if they had to repay supplementary support they had been forced to take while waiting for ACC support to come through.

“It simply isn’t fair that people who have acted in good faith have, for whatever reason, got an injury due to no fault of their own and are left in a worse situation when trying to seek support from MSD and ACC.

“Many sick and injured Kiwis took welfare payments while their ACC claims were being heard, they’re also some of the poorest and hardest working members of society.”

Jackson said if the law was retrospectively passed it would effectively criminalise people who need help, not debt.

“Many took those welfare payments because they had no other option while waiting for their ACC claim, they didn’t know at all that they would face a claw back and took the money in good conscience.

“So we must remember, and sometimes people forget about these people…but these people are not criminals, yet the feeling that we picked up from some of the submitters is that they made to feel like criminals when they’re burdened with debt and they really should be supported.”

Jackson suggested Labour would only support the bill at third reading if MSD was given clear discretion to not recover payments that would cause further hardship and inequity – and not claw back disability and rehab allowances.

He also said Labour’s support required an exemption for victims of abuse in state care.

“That certainly would placate a lot of our people who made submissions…we don’t believe that that should be so hard for us as a House to consider.”

New Zealand First’s Jamie Arbuckle said his party had raised concerns at first reading about unintended consequences and wanted to look at “some of the finer points to make some changes” at the committee of the whole house stage.

The bill has progressed with the support of National, New Zealand First, ACT and Labour, with the Greens, Te Pāti Māori and independent MPs Mariameno Kapa-Kingi and Tākuta Ferris opposed.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

LiveNews: https://nz.mil-osi.com/2026/03/03/labour-changes-tune-on-welfare-claw-backs/